The International Journal of Urban Labour and Leisure - Article Review Form.
 

 

The following criteria should not necessarily be used as rejection / acceptance criteria, but are headings which you might find useful in assessing the article. (All reviews returned to authors will be made anonymous)

Review

Reviewer name:

Reviewers Email Address:

Article title:

(1) Practical applications - are implications for practitioners clearly drawn out?

(2) Research applications - does the article suggest areas for further research?

(3) Clarity and readability - is attention paid to clarity of expression and readability? Points to note; sentence structure, jargon, acronyms.

(4) Originality - does it add to the subject area / body of knowledge in any way?

(5) Analytical rigour - does the article demonstrate soundness in the way in which it has been researched and/or argued?

(6) Internationality - will the article be of interest to an international audience?

(7) Recommendations - please select one of the following

Accept Revise Reject

(8) Please specify any other revision criteria.

Menu Options:

Home
About
Issues
Info
Editors
Submit

Book Reviews
Chat
Search
Guestbook
Forum

 

IJULL Last Updated: 1999-2004 International Journal of Urban Labour and Leisure

ttp://www.ijull.co.uk/">International Journal of Urban Labour and Leisure